Blog

You’ve worked hard to get stable. You’ve found a treatment plan that’s helping—maybe medication, therapy, or both. You’re starting to feel like yourself again.

Then a new provider tells you:

“I don’t think you have bipolar disorder.”

“You seem fine—you probably don’t need those meds anymore.”

Now you’re confused. Were you misdiagnosed? Do you still need treatment? Could you be fine without it?

At Oak Health Center, we’ve seen how conflicting opinions between providers can cause distress, doubt, and in some cases, serious setbacks. This is especially common with conditions like bipolar disorder, where symptoms can vary and diagnosis is complex.

Here’s how to navigate those situations—without compromising your progress.

1. Be Cautious of Confirmation Bias

It’s completely human to want to be “done” with treatment. You may prefer the idea that you don’t have a lifelong condition. Or you may not like how medications make you feel. So when someone tells you what you want to hear—“You don’t really need this”—it can feel like a green light to stop.

That’s confirmation bias: the tendency to embrace information that aligns with what you already hope is true.

The risk? You may discontinue treatment too early, or without a full clinical picture—which can lead to relapse or emotional instability.

2. Understand That Labels Aren’t Perfect

Mental health diagnoses aren’t like blood tests. They’re based on patterns of symptoms, history, and observed behaviors. Different providers may interpret things differently, especially in short visits or with incomplete records.

For example:

• You may be stable now because your medication is working—not because you were misdiagnosed.
  
• A provider may not see symptoms if they’re not present in the moment.
  
• Past manic or depressive episodes may be overlooked if not discussed in detail.
  

It’s not about who’s “right.” It’s about ensuring that all relevant history and data are considered before making major changes.

3. Avoid Making Sudden Changes Without a Plan

Stopping medication or therapy cold turkey—especially for conditions like bipolar disorder, major depression, or schizophrenia—can be dangerous.

If a provider suggests stopping a treatment that’s been working, ask:

• What information are you basing this on?
  
• Have you reviewed my full history and prior assessments?
  
• Can we consult with my previous provider before making a change?
  
• What’s the plan if symptoms return?
  

You deserve collaborative care—not snap decisions.

4. Coordinate Care Between Providers

When possible, ask your providers to communicate directly with each other. This helps ensure that new opinions are informed by your full clinical picture.

At Oak Health Center, we believe in integrated, team-based care—where psychiatrists, therapists, and primary care providers work together to make sure you’re supported from every angle.

If you’re seeing a new nurse practitioner, therapist, or PCP, it’s helpful to authorize a records release or ask your Oak clinician to reach out for a collaborative consult.

5. Be Honest About What You’re Feeling

Sometimes, providers downplay a diagnosis because you seem fine. But that might be because your treatment is working.

If you’re stable because of medication, say so.

If you’ve experienced symptoms in the past but they’re gone now, share that too.

You are the expert on your lived experience. The more clearly you communicate your history, the better your providers can support you.

6. When in Doubt, Get a Second (Coordinated) Opinion

If you’re feeling uncertain, that’s valid. But the solution isn’t to stop treatment based on one offhand comment. It’s to seek a coordinated, thoughtful second opinion from a specialist who has time to dig deep.

Our team at Oak Health Center includes psychiatrists, therapists, and diagnostic professionals who can help clarify your diagnosis and build a plan that works for you—not against you.

You Deserve Consistent, Informed Care

If your care team isn’t on the same page, you can feel caught in the middle. That’s why we advocate for clear communication, thorough evaluations, and treatment decisions based on your full history—not just a 15-minute impression.

If you’re navigating conflicting feedback or uncertain about your next steps, we’re here to help.

Schedule a confidential consultation

Learn more about our psychiatric services and therapy options

Explore collaborative care across our multi-specialty team